We don’t rent cars all that often. We’ve become more comfortable taking public transportation to/from the airport in major cities like New York and Chicago and then using Uber/Lyft/Taxi and sometimes public transportation to get around whatever city or town we’re in. We only need a rental car on trips when we go to places where public transportation isn’t an option (like when we flew to NC and then went to South of the Border).
So why is it that on about 50% of our trips pre-COVID, there were no available cars when we got to the rental car counter/garage?
This problem has only gotten worse with a decreased rental car inventory and rapidly increasing demand. But if we’re honest, this isn’t a new problem for rental car companies. I get the concept of overbooking because airlines do it all the time. Hotels even do it, but not as often. Rental car companies seem to plan on people not showing up for car rentals.
I understand that not everyone will return a car when they say that they will. People do sometimes run late (and companies charge you for an extra rental day when you do). This fact makes it difficult for rental car companies to schedule when a car will be ready to rent to a new customer. However, this doesn’t explain why I’ve twice shown up to rental car lots with no cars. None. Zip. Nada. Now, while I wanted to re-enact this Seinfeld scene, I remained calm and kept my mouth shut.
Apparently, this is our reality so we must learn what to do when this happens (notice I said when and not if). Hopefully, you won’t need to be somewhere right away (like you planned your flight THAT CLOSE a wedding or graduation). If you do, you need to weigh your options and take action ASAP. This may mean renting from another company if there are any cars available or taking a car service. If getting to your destination is more important than the money it’ll require to do so, bite the bullet and worry about the rest later.
If you have the time to wait it out, here are some tips based on our rules for being a better customer:
- Let the staff know your requirements. Both times we were waiting for cars, we were upfront about what we would and wouldn’t accept. Would we take a bigger car? What about a smaller one? Do we need room for luggage? If you’re traveling with four adults with luggage, you’re not going to be happy about getting a compact car when you reserved a full-sized one. We were very frank with the staff when we were taking a car for a one-way rental that whichever car they gave us would not be coming back.
- Be friendly. It’s not the staff in the garage who rented too many cars. They are not any happier about dealing with unhappy customers than you are that they’re out of cars. Being “that guy” won’t help you get a car any faster. Having them on your side at this moment will be a plus.
- Be flexible. Work with the staff to come to a reasonable outcome. You might not get the car your want, but you’ll have a car. Would you be able to come back tomorrow to exchange the car for one more like the one you reserved? Would that be OK with you and with them?
- Be patient. You can’t wish a car back to the garage and neither can they. If you’ve decided to wait it out, then wait. No tapping your foot while waiting; just wait. Play Candy Crush on your phone. Catch up on your Instagram posts. Watch TikTok videos. Have a nice chat with the staff. This was how we found out the reason there were no cars in Phoenix. It was Parents’ Weekend at the area colleges and every one of those parents needed to rent a car. Even with the staff driving 4-5 times a day to area locations, they still couldn’t get enough cars to the airport.
- If you need to cut and run, check if other agencies have cars available. You may even be able to get the difference in cost refunded by the original rental car agency. Just be prepared to stand your ground with your complaint. If you make a reasonable request for compensation, you may be able to get something back in return.
So what happened during our rentals? Keep in mind, both of these instances were on the first day of a trip where all we had planned for the evening was driving to our hotel and getting something to eat before heading to bed. For our first rental, we needed to sit for about 20 minutes before the desk agent walked to us and handed us a set of keys. She asked if it would be OK for us to take a Jeep Cherokee even though we rented a mid-size car. I said we’d be fine with that and it must have been karma since the reason we were in town was to visit the Jeep-boree (Note from Sharon: No dear, that’s what YOU call it. It was the Great Smoky Mountain Jeep Invasion.) (Note from Joe: I know. But my name for it is faster and funnier.).
The other time we were “carless” was, as I mentioned above, in Phoenix. We waited in the garage with the staff for about 20-30 minutes. Several options were floated to us and we were willing to go along with whatever solution they came up with. Eventually, a manager came over to us, thanked us for our patience and asked if I would be all right with taking a Dodge Charger. I asked if they considered that a “sport” car but he assured me that it was categorized as a mid-size. I’d never pay to rent a sports car but if you are going to give me one, who am I to turn it down? It was nice to have the extra pickup when passing cars driving along the desert roads between Phoenix, Sedona, Grand Canyon and Las Vegas. I had to be extra careful about watching the speedometer because it was very easy to look down and see a speed that I had no business driving.
It’s clear that overbooked rental car agencies are a thing, just like overbooked planes and oversold hotels. Unlike those situations where compensation is spelled out in advance or is even governmentally regulated, there’s currently no requirement for a rental car company to do anything if they don’t have a car. Knowing the possibility exists, weighing your options and working with the staff is always the better way out of these situations. Just don’t lose your s**t and become “that person” at the counter.
Want to comment on this post? Great! Read this first to help ensure it gets approved.
Want to sponsor a post, write something for Your Mileage May Vary or put ads on our site? Click here for more info.
Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love it if you decided to hang around and sign up to get emailed notifications of when we post.
Whether you’ve read our articles before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!
This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary