Home Airlines I Barely Avoided Making This Mistake When Booking An American Flight

I Barely Avoided Making This Mistake When Booking An American Flight

by joeheg

We haven’t had the best luck when flying with on American Airlines. On our only trip this year, we were proactively offered a bump voucher to take a later flight. Then the flight we were put on instead was delayed and delayed and undelayed. The hassle was worth it because we each received a $400 voucher that was good for a year and all we needed to do was find a flight where we could use the credit.

Unfortunately for us, American Airlines doesn’t offer many non-stop flights from Orlando. There was one trip we could have flown with American but it was for a connecting flight and with their operational problems this year, we avoided them and booked with Frontier instead.

But now it’s approaching a year and we need to think about using our vouchers. I found flights for an upcoming trip that made sense and were the perfect price.

And then I realized the mistake I was so close to making.

There were two possible itineraries between Orlando and San Francisco. One of them had a connection in Dallas and the other in Charlotte.

While flying to Charlotte might seem out of the way, it only adds about 250 miles to the trip. On a cross-country flight, that’s a fraction of the flying distance and not much longer flight time.

The flights through Dallas are two hours shorter due to a more favorable connection but they cost $100 more per ticket and for some people that could be worth taking the longer trip.

Screen Shot 2019-11-28 at 1.18.39 PM

Looking a little closer at American’s website, I noticed something missing. See that little power plug symbol showing on the bottom flights that are missing from the ones on the top. That’s the indicator for in-seat power. The flights through Charlotte are both on ex-US Airways A321 planes, as are many of American’s planes that fly through Charlotte. This isn’t surprising as it was a former US Airways hub. While American has invested to install Wi-Fi on these planes, they still do not have seat-back entertainment or power. That means no plugs for a computer and not even a USB connector to charge a phone.

I can deal with a shorter flight on a plane with no power, but the flight from CLT-SFO is blocked at 5:48. That’s almost 6 hours in an uncomfortable economy seat. With my laptop. if I’m using Wi-Fi I’ll be able to get 2 hours, maybe 3 hours tops, of power from the battery. So much for getting work done on the plane if we take those flights.

Flying through Dallas will split the trip into two generally equal segments with a time to get up and stretch (or more likely run to get from one gate to another). The flight to Dallas is on one of American A321’s with seatback entertainment and power outlets. The DFW-SFO flight is on a 737 which has the new American interior design featuring a tablet/phone holder. These planes do have power outlets for your own devices.

What could be an even worse flight that one with no power or entertainment? Here’s a return flight where the plane doesn’t even show as having Wi-FI. This might just be a glitch on the website as American has supposedly installed Wi-Fi on all of their A321 planes, even the former US Airways ones.

Screen Shot 2019-11-28 at 1.36.01 PM

I’d chalk this up to being an oversight but this isn’t the only flight showing with no Wi-Fi so either it’s a larger technology error on American’s side or there are plenty of flights I wouldn’t want to be on between Charlotte and San Francisco.

Final Thoughts

I guarantee you that the majority of people searching for a flight aren’t looking to see if the plane has seatback entertainment, power outlets or even Wi-Fi. They’re shopping for price and for the best schedule. That’s why American Airlines can get away with offering a sub-standard product on some of their planes for the past six years (and no plans to install power or IFE anytime soon). People may be disappointed when they board when they see no seatback screen. They’ll be more upset when there are no plugs and then the final hit will be if there’s no Wi-Fi.

Consistency is the main problem. In order to know what you’re getting when booking a flight on American, you have to dig into their website a little. At least after doing so, you’ll be an educated consumer and can make a decision if you’d want to pay for a better plane or will you be OK on the bare-bones version.

And then there’s always a possibility of a change of planes and all of your hard work will be for nothing. Airlines don’t promise any amenity in their contracts, only eventually getting you from point A to B. No more, no less.

Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love if you decided to hang around and clicked the button on the top (if you’re on your computer) or the bottom (if you’re on your phone/tablet) of this page to follow our blog and get emailed notifications of when we post (it’s usually about 3 or 4 times a day). Or maybe you’d like to join our Facebook group, where we talk and ask questions about travel (including Disney parks), creative ways to earn frequent flyer miles and hotel points, how to save money on or for your trips, get access to travel articles you may not see otherwise, etc. Whether you’ve read our posts before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!

This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary




Ty Vilhauer November 29, 2019 - 2:10 pm

Or you could just have a battery pack and none of this is an actual problem. The real issue is the 757’s with no WiFi.

Randy November 29, 2019 - 6:43 pm

The DFW flights are actually three hours shorter, not two. Read the total trip time: 11hrs vs 8hrs.

joeheg November 29, 2019 - 10:21 pm

Right you are, I was looking at the arrival times.

mojo November 29, 2019 - 7:36 pm

“What could be an even worse flight that one with no power or entertainment?”

A flight that you specifically booked because it said that it *had* power/entertainment, only it doesn’t work.
Or, AA does a last-minute equipment change and your actual aircraft doesn’t have it after all.

Bring an extra battery and who cares.

joeheg November 29, 2019 - 10:21 pm

So while you or I might know to bring a power brick just-in-case American does an equipment swap. what about everone else who has no idea what that means and thought their plane would have a power outlet or wi-fi or paid extra to be on a flight with those services.

Tony November 29, 2019 - 9:09 pm

“That’s why American Airlines can get away with offering a sub-standard product on some of their planes for the past six years (and no plans to install power or IFE anytime soon)”

You literally said you book Frontier over American. And then you fault American for not having plugs or IFE…

Which airline do you think doesn’t have any of that at all? lol what a joke.

joeheg November 29, 2019 - 10:04 pm

I consider the two situations differently because I know that Frontier isn’t going to provide power or Wi-Fi. We’ll only fly then for trips of 3 hours or less. On American, flying for 6 hours for a cabin similar to what Frontier offers but charges much more for is unacceptable.


Leave a Comment