We’ve Decided CLEAR Is Not Worth It For Us. Here’s Why…

Back in December, I finally signed us up for CLEAR. That’s the service that gives you an express lane access past the TSA ID checkpoint. I had a free trial membership with TripIt Pro for three months and a free family membership so I figured we’d give it a shot. Well it’s been over six months and I’ve been able to use the CLEAR lanes a couple of times. As of now, I just don’t see how it’s worth the extra money they charge for the service. There are several things that led to this conclusion.:

Sharon and I had the same feeling after using CLEAR for the first three months. I had to renew my membership since my free trial was running out. I decided that just three months wasn’t enough time to make a conclusion on the matter. Her free trial was extended (because of some problems with her initial signup) so I’d only have to pay the $79 as a Delta co-brand credit cardholder to renew for another year. I figured after 15 months, I’d be able to make a definitive statement on if we found it worth the money.

I’ve decided to stop the trial early and release my findings.

If Sharon and I both had to renew, our cost would be $159 for a year’s membership for the two of us. New members would have to pay even more because CLEAR increased prices for Delta Skymiles members in April 2019.

For that price, it’s just not worth it for us.

Why We Haven’t Fallen In Love With CLEAR

1. It hasn’t saved us any time at our home airport

TSA

The TSA Checkpoint lines at Orlando Airport can be terrible. It’s gotten so bad that the airport now tells passengers to get to the ticketing counter no less than two hours before a flight. However most of the time to get through TSA checkpoints is spent waiting for ID and bag screening. Those are lines we hardly ever would need to stand in because we have TSA Pre-check. As we’ve walked to the CLEAR lanes, we’ve looked at the Pre-check lines and they’ve been almost empty. It’s almost seemed that between going to CLEAR and getting our fingerprints to work takes longer than the simple process of showing my boarding pass and ID to a TSA agent. (BTW, if CLEAR took a retinal scan, how come they never use it to verify identity?)

I understand this is a uniquely Orlando problem. The security lines at MCO are a mess  (here’s why we think that is) but we miss almost all of that just by having TSA Pre-check.

2. Places we’ve flown to just haven’t had CLEAR checkpoints

Our travel plans aren’t typical. We often fly to places that aren’t the most popular or we’re flying on the cheapest fare we can find. Those aren’t places CLEAR has outposts. Even when we flew to New York, our last two trips from JFK and LGA left from terminals that didn’t have CLEAR.

3. We tend to fly at unpopular times

If we’re flying using points or paying cash, we’re looking for the best deals. Those flights usually involve flying either before or after the frequent flyers want to be on the planes., so we tend to take a bunch of late morning/early afternoon or early evening flights. Checkpoints also tend to be less busy during those hours. Even at the places without CLEAR, we’re usually through security in less than 10 minutes.

This is totally a Your Mileage May Vary situation

I know some flyers who say that having CLEAR has been life changing for their travels. I don’t doubt that’s true. At other airports, the Pre-check line can be horrendous and that’s when CLEAR is a lifesaver. If you’re that person who’s stood in a 30-40 minute Pre-check line every week, CLEAR totally makes sense.

But for us, our travels and our experience, CLEAR just isn’t worth the extra cost. I have no doubt that we may come across a trip where having CLEAR saves us a significant amount of time. But for one or even two trips, is it worth $79 or $109? I’ll pay myself that money and wait patiently on line.

Now if only there could be a credit card that would offer a CLEAR membership as a perk (that would be different from the five cards I have that give me TSA Pre-Check or Global Entry fee reimbursements), then I’d consider it. Until that happens, I’ll use CLEAR until our membership expires and then go back in line with the rest of the people who have paid for TSA Pre-check.

Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love if you decided to hang around and clicked the button on the top (if you’re on your computer) or the bottom (if you’re on your phone/tablet) of this page to follow our blog and get emailed notifications of when we post (it’s usually just two or three times a day). Or maybe you’d like to join our Facebook group, where we talk and ask questions about travel (including Disney parks), creative ways to earn frequent flyer miles and hotel points, how to save money on or for your trips, get access to travel  articles you may not see otherwise, etc. Whether you’ve read our posts before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!

This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary

8 thoughts on “We’ve Decided CLEAR Is Not Worth It For Us. Here’s Why…”

  1. I never understood it. At best, it saves a few minutes. But it’s not in every terminal/airport and there have been times the CLEAR line has been longer than the PreCheck line.

  2. I can tell you averaging 100K domestic business travel a year that Clear is well worth it, yes sometimes I have seen the TSA lines short but that is an exception, Take SFO/SEA without Clear your toast. MCO I have never gone through where the TSA lines were slim to none but then I am going through between 7 am and 4pm on most of my flights.

    Good news your not renewing makes the lines shorter for us in Clear and longer in PreCK

  3. Totally agree! I’ve often felt the same way as you describe about the CLEAR line seeming to take longer than just walking through an empty Precheck line and handing over an ID. That’s based on my experience at MSP (I was a CLEAR member for one year but am no longer).

  4. Clear eye scanners are SUPER SLOW – like 3-4x as slow as fingerprint. They only use it when your fingerprint doesnt work. I love CLEAR because at SFO, SJC, LAS it seems like everyone has precheck so those lines can be super super long (especially SFO United at T3).

  5. I’ve had Clear for about 8 months now. Its totally worth it flying out of Atlanta. ATL security lanes are notoriously long, so its definitely worth it. If it saves you one missed flight, its paid for itself. 80% of the time I dont wait in line at all, I go str8 to Clear (which seldom has a line), then str8 to TSA… even tho the Only Regular Clear lane is on the South Delta Terminal Security Check Point. I usually fly American so if did not have a digital boarding pass; it would take longer. Which is why they REALLY NEED TO ADD A CLEAR LANE TO THE NORTH TERMINAL in ATL. Which is essentially my only complaint about Clear. They are not in enough Airports and even airports where they have presence, they are not at every security checkpoint. Fix that, and this service would be well worth it.
    The other cool thing is, they are adding Clear Lanes to Concerts & Sports Venues like the Mercedes Benz Stadium & SunTrust Park in ATL. Even us Falcons Season Tix Holders have to wait in line 20, 30, 40 mins to enter some times …this would be a game changer! 🙌🏽

  6. Clear is life saving in Denver – but I agree that I haven’t gotten great value from it other places.

    In my third year and pays for itself every holiday season.

  7. Clear is great. Sorry to see you go. Less folks to wait behind. Total time saver during holidays, regardless of airport where CLEAR exists.

  8. Claar probably saves me at least three hours a year at checkpoints versus pre-check, and an additional six hours in time I don’t spend at the airport. (I can safely arrive later knowing I will be through the checkpoint in less than five minutes flat no matter how long the lines are).

    So well worth the time savings and the peace of mind is priceless.

Leave a Reply