Redemption Level Sweet Spot Of The New Starbucks Rewards

On April 16, 2019, the changes to the Starbucks Rewards program took effect. While the earning of stars is still the same at two stars per dollar, the ways to redeem your stars changed significantly. Previously, you could redeem 125 stars for most food or drink items for sale at a Starbucks store, regardless of price. I always saved stars for when I wanted to pick up a lunch to take to work and cashed in 125 stars for a Chicken Wrap box, which sells for $7.95.

Starbucks has now divided items into tiers, with a different number of Stars needed to get a free item in each category. Here’s a breakdown of the new rewards structure:

IMG_7543

So if awards are now divided by categories, where’s the sweet spot for redemptions?

25 Point Rewards

If you like to customize your drinks, this category is for you. From what I can find, getting almond milk in your drink instead of regular milk costs an extra 60 cents. Adding an extra shot to your latte will set you back 90 cents.

Redeeming 25 stars for these add-ons will get you anywhere from 2.4 to 3.6 CPS (Cents Per Star). Since redemptions for the lowest level awards are hardly ever a great value, what about the new 50 point level…?

50 Point Rewards

This new level lets you redeem points for brewed coffee, hot tea or bakery items. Previously, these inexpensive items weren’t worth wasting a 125 point reward on, so what about now?

The least expensive item might be a cookie pop, which costs $2.25. My usual cold weather drink, for the month it gets cold enough in Florida to drink blazing hot coffee from Starbucks, is a Venti Blonde Roast with Half & Half and 2 Splenda.

IMG_7555

The only more expensive item I could find on the menu was a Banana Nut Loaf, which runs $3.15.

That puts the redemption value for rewards at this level between 4.5 and 6.3 CPS

150 Point Rewards

This is point level that I’m sure most closely matches the redemptions many people were making with their stars – coffee drinks. This level now includes breakfast sandwiches and parfaits, “cause everyone loves parfait” (if anyone gets this reference, please reply and let me know).

Before looking at coffee drinks, let’s view what might be the worst redemption ever. Never should you ever use 150 stars to get a $2.25 KIND bar.

IMG_7557

Maybe calories have no meaning to you and you order a Venti Triple Mocha Frappuccino. That’s a $6.25 drink for 150 stars.

IMG_7560

While that may seem good, you caffeine fiends who like to add extra shots are in luck. You can add extra shots and still only pay 150 stars, like this Grande Caffe Latte with two extra shots for $6.45.

IMG_7558

I’m sure there are ways to make more expensive drinks but the idea is also for them to be drinkable as well. Since breakfast sandwiches and parfaits fall in the middle of the price range, figure that you’ll get anywhere from 1.5 to 4.3 CPS for redemptions in this category.

200 Point Rewards

This category includes the lunch items I used to get with my rewards. Since redemptions for these items have gone up 60% from their previous level, are they still worth it?

A PB&J Protein box goes for $5.95 and a Chicken Wrap Protein Box (which still has peanut sauce but they no longer label it as Thai Chicken Wraps) goes for $7.95. Get anywhere from 2.975 to 3.975 CPS value for redemptions in the category. Not nearly as good as you received before. 

400 Point Rewards

This new Mega level reward includes at-home coffee and select merchandise. Our coffee of choice at home, Veranda Blonde Roast, goes for $12.95.

IMG_7556

Other bagged coffee, like Sumatra or some of the Passport series blends, can go for up to $14.95 per bag. That will give you a value of 3.23 to 3.73 CPS.

So Where’s the Sweet Spot?

I was surprised to find out the best category to redeem rewards under the new program is the 50 point level. Even the worst redemption at that level, a $2.25 cake pop, will be a better value than an expensive coffee drink at the 150 point level.

My Venti Blonde Roast or a Banana Nut Loaf for 50 Stars get a value of over 6 cents per star, by far the best redemption value of any category.

So while it used to make sense to redeem your stars for the most expensive items on the menu, the new Starbucks Rewards program gives you the best value if you redeem for the basic menu items like drip coffee or bakery items.

If you know of any hack to get a better value from any of the categories, I’d love to find out what you’ve discovered over the past week.

Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love if you decided to hang around and clicked the button on the top (if you’re on your computer) or the bottom (if you’re on your phone/tablet) of this page to follow our blog and get emailed notifications of when we post (it’s usually just two or three times a day). Or maybe you’d like to join our Facebook group, where we talk and ask questions about travel (including Disney parks), creative ways to earn frequent flyer miles and hotel points, how to save money on or for your trips, get access to travel articles you may not see otherwise, etc. Whether you’ve read our posts before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!

This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary

15 thoughts on “Redemption Level Sweet Spot Of The New Starbucks Rewards”

  1. Thanks for the breakdown! I was wondering the value of each tier. I also used to save my stars for “big ticket” items because there was no real cap before. Although I did just redeem 150 stars for a venti macchiato drink, but I’ll have to start using the 50 star level to maximize my rewards, I think.

      1. @HHC Nice! On the website it’s listed under Hot Breakfast, but in the app it’s under Bakery. So for the exact same cost ($3.75) as the sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich (150 stars), you’re getting triple the redemption value (50 stars).

    1. Thanks for this post! Very helpful and I enjoyed the extra laugh “everybody love parfait” that ain’t no brimstone either!

  2. @HHC Agreed. A ham and cheese croissant and a venti Caffe Misto (aka Cafe au Lait) for 100 stars total – around 7 cps and way better than the previous 125 for a latte. This “devaluation” has got me going back to Starbucks!!

  3. Cafe Misto for 50 stars, and you can add extra shots, flavors, toppings for free – is close enough to a latte for me!

    1. You are a genius. I just tried that in my app and I was amazed. Thank You! They’ll probably catch on soon though….boooo!

  4. I created a Reward Value Calculator to help me decide what’s redemption worthy at Starbucks! All you need to do is plug in the price of the item and the number of Stars to redeem, and it will rate your reward from Terrible to Excellent! Check it out!! https://starbuckshacker.com/reward-value-calculator/

    For example, in my home state of Massachusetts, BBQ Chips will cost you $1.75. Using 150 Stars to redeem only gives you a 2.33% return, the Reward Value Calculator classifies this reward as Terrible.
    A slice of Banana Nut Bread cost me $2.95, using 50 Stars to redeem give me an 11.8% return, the Reward Value Calculator classifies this reward as Excellent! 🙂

    1. Thank you. This is very helpful. I’ve become less thrilled over the 10 years I’ve been a member.

Leave a Reply