It’s a question that’s been asked a bajillion times ever since Walt Disney World (WDW) opened nearly 50 years ago – should you rent a car while there, or no? The answer is as complicated now as it was in 1971 because there are lots of things to take into consideration. Let’s go through them and it might help you decide.
Where are you staying?
Some people stay on Disney property, at one of the Disney-run resort hotels. Other people stay off-site. Which one to do is its own huge decision, but we go over that in this post.
If you stay on site, you’ll have access to the Disney transportation system, in the form of buses, monorails, boats and, soon, gondolas to get you from your hotel to anywhere else in the World and back. They’re all free, but during busy times of the day, those modes of transportation are usually crowded and you may have to wait for an unpacked bus or stand for the whole ride.
If you stay off-site, you’ll need to get from your hotel to WDW and back, and your hotel may or may not have a shuttle. If it does have one, you’ll still have to go by the shuttle’s times, which may or may not work with your park plans of when you want to arrive and leave. If it doesn’t have one, you’re on your own in terms of getting to WDW and back.
What do you want to see & where do you want to go in Central FL?
Some people are perfectly happy to go straight from the airport to their hotel on Disney property and never leave until it’s time to go back to the airport – many call it “staying in the Disney bubble.”
Others like to be more adventurous and experience places other than Disney…maybe other parks, shopping, restaurants, etc. When I lived in NY and visited Orlando, I used to enjoy driving around various neighborhoods, to get an idea of what it was like to live there :-).
What’s more important to you in terms of time, money, comfort, etc.?
Renting a car means paying more money for your vacation. However it also means saving time getting from one place to another, not being squished in and/or using your vacation time to visit places other than WDW.
The Pros and Cons of Each
Now that we’ve gone through the different factors that would affect your decision of whether or not to rent a car while visiting Central FL, let’s make it easy and just break down the pros and cons of each:
Renting a car – Pros
- Speed. If you’re staying on WDW property, it’s usually faster than taking Disney-provided transportation.
- Speed & price. If you’re staying off WDW property, it’s almost always faster than the hotel-provided shuttle bus and much faster than taxi/Uber/city bus. It might also cost less than the fees some hotels charge for shuttle bus usage.
- Freedom. You have more freedom to go wherever you want, whenever you want.
- Comfort. Sitting in a car, with your stuff in the trunk, is more comfortable than potentially standing on a crowded bus, holding your kid, bags and “stuff.”
Renting a car – Cons
- Cost. Granted you can sometimes find really cheap prices for a rental car and you can even time your flights to save money on your rental car. But you also have to take insurance, tolls, parking fees and gas info consideration.
Using Disney transportation or a shuttle – Pros
- Cost. Disney transportation is free. Off-site hotel shuttles may be free or may cost less than a rental car (I know I said it could be more expensive above – it depends on the cost of the shuttle vs. whatever deal you can get on a rental car).
- No confusion. If you have a lousy sense of direction, you’re letting someone else figure out how to get from Point A to Point B.
- Distance: For most Disney parks, cars need to park in the parking lot and then guests take a tram to the park. For the Magic Kingdom, cars need to park at the Ticket & Transportation Center and then guests need to take a monorail or ferry to the park. Disney transportation drops you off much closer to the entrance of the parks.
Using Disney transportation or a shuttle – Cons
- Speed. You have to wait for the next bus/monorail/boat/gondola, or for whatever time the shuttle is scheduled to come. During bad weather, boats and gondolas may be temporarily shut down.
- Price. Off-site hotels may charge a per-person fee for use of their shuttle. Depending on what you’re paying for the rental car, a shuttle might be more expensive.
- Freedom. With a shuttle, you can’t come and go as you please, and with either, you can’t go wherever in Central FL you want.
- Comfort: You might have to stand and hold all your stuff on Disney/hotel transportation.
How to have the best of both worlds
Some people plan their trip so they only use a rental car for a couple of days – say, to go to Universal one day, Sea World the next, the outlets another day and then they plan to use available transportation for the rest of their trip. If you ask me, it’s a good compromise and will cost less than renting a car for the entire trip, when there could be days when you could make do without a rental car.
We’ve already written some articles about this subject that may help you decide. Check them out:
- How To Get A Cheap Rental Car
- Timing Your Flights To Save You Money On Your Rental Car
- Signing Up For Car Rental Programs And What Each One Will Give You
- Should You Get The Three Types Of Car Rental Insurance?
- How To Avoid Crazy toll Charges When Renting A Car In Orlando
- Effective September 1, 2018, E-ZPass Can Be Used On Central Florida Expressway Authority Roadways!
- Why Do Hotels Charge For Parking? And How Can You Get Around Having To Pay For It?
- The History of Avoiding Parking Fees At WDW Parks (And Our Suggestions Of What To Do Nowadays)
- WDW Hotels Aren’t The Only Places Where You Now Have To Pay For Parking
- Should You Prepay For Gas With Your Rental Car?
- Rented A Car at MCO & Now Returning It? Don’t Fill Your Gas/Petrol Tank Up Here!
- The Closest Places To MCO To Get “Normal” Priced Gas/Petrol Before Returning Your Rental Car
- Late Returning Your Rental Car? It Could Cost You An Extra Day’s Rental Charge
- The Absolute Least Expensive Way to Travel Off Disney/Universal Property (Or Nearly Anywhere in Central Florida)
- Uber, Lyft & Minnie Vans at WDW: Comparing NEW PRICING STRUCTURE & Value (Updated Oct., 2018)
- How To Find Out How Much A Taxi Will Cost, Ahead of Time, While Traveling
Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love if you decided to hang around and clicked the button on the top (if you’re on your computer) or the bottom (if you’re on your phone/tablet) of this page to follow our blog and get emailed notifications of when we post (it’s usually just two or three times a day). Or maybe you’d like to join our Facebook group, where we talk and ask questions about travel (including Disney parks), creative ways to earn frequent flyer miles and hotel points, how to save money on or for your trips, get access to travel articles you may not see otherwise, etc. Whether you’ve read our posts before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!
This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary