Beware of This Car Rental Nightmare

I’ve been renting cars for over 20 years. I’ve seen many of the tricks and know how to avoid many of them. I sign up for the car rental programs so I don’t have to go through the pitch for insurance coverage. I always decline the prepaid fuel purchase because that’s for suckers. However with all my knowledge, I was almost caught in a trap when returning a car to the airport.  How’d they get me? Read on…


My car was in the shop and wouldn’t be done by the weekend. The repair shop didn’t have any loaners but luckily I was able to find a really cheap rental from the airport for the weekend by using Autoslash. Not to slander any company, but I think the name rhymed with Mavis.

I rented my car from the airport kiosk. I didn’t have to speak to anyone; I just had to enter my reservation and was directed to the parking lot to get my car. I picked a car and proceeded to leave the lot. I noticed the car only had 1/2 a tank of gas when I left but didn’t think anything of it. I’ve rented cars from local spots before that have said “You have 1/2 a tank now, just return it with 1/2 a tank.” Besides, I was only taking the car for a short weekend rental, so I figured no problem.

So I used the car for the couple of days and went to return it when I was done. The check in agent printed my receipt with a charge for $40 of fuel. I asked why and she told me that the car only had 1/2 a tank so I’d have to pay for the rest of the fuel at $4.50 a gallon. WHAT?!?!?!?! No, I only rented the car with 1/2 a tank.

She assured me that was impossible as all cars go out with a full tank. If I wanted to dispute this, I’d have to go inside the airport and complain at the counter. UGH! Luckily, I was not leaving for a flight. If I was, there was no way I could have waited in line to straighten this out.


The airport counter line. The one thing I try to avoid only slightly more than the plague.

After waiting behind people with every type of rental problem imaginable, I got to speak to an agent. I calmly explained that when I rented my car it only had 1/2 of a tank of gas. I returned it with the same amount of gas but the agent in the garage charged me for the difference.

I was again told all their cars leave with a full tank. If my car wasn’t full, I should’ve told them when leaving. I replied that I have rented cars with less than a full tank before and was only responsible for bringing the car back with amount of fuel I received it with.

I asked to speak with the shift manager at this point, since my point was getting me nowhere. Obviously he thought I didn’t want to pay for the fuel. End of story.

The manager showed up and I explained my situation. He again told me that they fill up all the cars before renting them. I said that they must have missed one. I then tried to use the only thing I had left on my side, MATH!

I asked how many miles I drove the car. “50 miles,” he replied.

How large is the fuel tank? “14 gallons,” he replied.

I said, “So 1/2 a tank would be 7 gallons of gas then?” He nodded in agreement.

I then asked, “What’s the average fuel mileage of this car?”

He said he didn’t know, but probably around 20 MPG.

“So 7 gallons at 20 MPG would be how much driving?,” I asked.

“140 miles,” he replied.

“And how far did I drive the car?”

“50 miles.”

So if I received the car with a full tank of gas and drove 50 miles, how does it only have 1/2 a tank left?

At this point he seemed to agree that it was more likely I didn’t get the car with a full tank of gas instead of thinking I siphoned the gas from the tank or sat idling the car for hours on end. He adjusted my rental agreement and removed the $40 charge for the fuel.  I did enjoy where the manager had to explain to the rental agent why it was impossible for me to have used more fuel when I only drove 50 miles.

Final Thoughts

So what’s the moral of the story?

  1. If I ever rent a car and it has less than a full tank, I make sure to have that in writing somewhere before I leave.
  2. Be calm but forceful if you’re right. Don’t get angry. You may eventually be able to convince a manager that you’re correct.
  3. MATH RULES!!!!!!!

Have you ever had a situation like this? How did it turn out? Let us know!

Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love if you decided to hang around and clicked the button on the top (if you’re on your computer) or the bottom (if you’re on your phone/tablet) of this page to follow our blog and get emailed notifications of when we post (it’s usually just two or three times a day). Or maybe you’d like to join our Facebook group, where we talk and ask questions about travel (including Disney parks), creative ways to earn frequent flyer miles and hotel points, how to save money on or for your trips, get access to travel  articles you may not see otherwise, etc. Whether you’ve read our posts before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!

This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary


3 thoughts on “Beware of This Car Rental Nightmare”

Leave a Reply